Movie & OTT Reviews, Gaming News & Trailers


Ebenezer Review: 12 Things That Decide Johnny Depp’s Gothic Christmas Carol Ebenezer Review: 12 Things That Decide Johnny Depp’s Gothic Christmas Carol
3
Ebenezer review: Johnny Depp is a dry, slow-thawing Scrooge and Ti West's Hammer-style London looks terrific, but a safe script and an underused supporting... Ebenezer Review: 12 Things That Decide Johnny Depp’s Gothic Christmas Carol

Filmoria Review

Johnny Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge tipping his top hat on a Victorian London street in Ti West's Ebenezer (2026)
Johnny Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge in Ti West’s Ebenezer. Official image © Paramount Pictures, via the official trailer.

Ebenezer, Ti West’s gothic version of A Christmas Carol with Johnny Depp as Scrooge, has been in UK and US cinemas since Friday 13 November 2026, released by Paramount. Filmoria gives it 3 out of 5: Depp is a genuinely good Scrooge and the film looks terrific, but it plays Dickens far safer than its horror-director pedigree promises. It runs 1 hour 56 minutes and is rated PG-13 in the US for frightening material.

Filmoria’s verdict: A handsome, occasionally spooky and well-acted Christmas Carol that never quite finds a reason to exist beyond Depp’s very decent turn in the top hat.

Filmoria Verdict Card

3 / 5 ★★★☆☆

Depp’s Scrooge and the Hammer-style design are the reasons to go. The cautious script and thin supporting roles are the reasons it stays a three.

Quick Facts

  • Director: Ti West (X, Pearl, MaXXXine)
  • Writers: Nathaniel Halpern (screenplay), from the 1843 novella by Charles Dickens
  • Cast: Johnny Depp, Ian McKellen, Andrea Riseborough, Tramell Tillman, Rupert Grint, Sam Claflin, Daisy Ridley, Arthur Conti, Ellie Bamber, Henry Lloyd-Hughes, Charlie Murphy
  • Producer: Emma Watts
  • Music: Tyler Bates
  • Runtime: 116 minutes (1 hour 56 minutes)
  • Release date: 13 November 2026 (UK, Ireland and US cinemas)
  • Rating: PG-13 in the US (frightening material); Filmoria score 3/5

In the UK

  • UK release: in UK and Irish cinemas now, from Friday 13 November 2026, released by Paramount Pictures International.
  • Where to watch: cinemas only for now. Streaming, digital and home release dates are not yet confirmed for the UK.
  • BBFC rating: not yet confirmed for the UK in the sources we checked. The US rating is PG-13 for frightening material, and Ti West himself calls it “hard-PG”.
  • Coming up: The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping opens against it on Friday 20 November 2026, so the bigger screens may move on quickly.

This is a ranked list of the 12 things that decide whether Ti West’s Ebenezer is worth your cinema ticket this Christmas, ending in Filmoria’s final verdict.

We’ve ordered the points by how much each one shapes the film, starting with Johnny Depp’s central performance and the story setup, moving through the cast, direction, craft and scares, then comparisons with earlier versions and other critics, and finishing with who it’s for. Ratings in the table are Filmoria’s own, out of five.

#AspectRatingVerdict
1Johnny Depp’s Scrooge4/5His best work in years, funny and sour
2Story and setup2.5/5Faithful, familiar, rarely surprising
3Ian McKellen’s Marley3.5/5A strong, extended opening
4The spirits4/5Riseborough is the standout spirit
5Supporting cast2.5/5Grint, Claflin and Ridley underused
6Ti West’s direction3/5Controlled, but reined in
7Look and sound4.5/5Hammer colours and a fine Tyler Bates score
8Scares3/5Hard-PG jolts, not real horror
9The ‘gray’ Scrooge3/5A good idea that’s only half-used
10Against other Carols2.5/5Below the Muppets and Alastair Sim
11Critical consensusNot applicable54% on Rotten Tomatoes, 90% audience score
12Who it’s forNot applicableAdults and teens who want a darker Christmas

1. Johnny Depp’s Scrooge (Ebenezer, 2026, Paramount)

What makes it stand out: Depp gives a sly, controlled and genuinely funny Scrooge that’s easily the best thing in the film.

Key data: It’s Depp’s first film for a major Hollywood studio since Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald in 2018, and he reportedly took around $5 million to play the part.

Why it matters: The whole film, and most of its marketing, rests on whether you believe Depp as Scrooge, and you do.

Let’s get the obvious bit out of the way. You’ll walk into Ebenezer with an opinion about Johnny Depp, and the film knows it. What surprised me is how little that matters once he’s on screen. This isn’t the twitchy, eyeliner-heavy Depp of the Pirates years. Under a lot of prosthetic ageing, he plays Scrooge small and dry, with a deadpan sneer that gets real laughs in the first half hour.

His best choice is not to rush the change. A lot of Scrooges flip from miser to saint in the final ten minutes, as if someone threw a switch. Depp lets it creep in, a flicker of regret here, a half-swallowed apology there, and when the turn finally comes it feels earned rather than scheduled. Mike BC at But Why Tho? singled out the same thing, and I agree with him: the comic timing comes through the make-up, mostly in the eyes and mouth.

He isn’t perfect. The ghost scenes push him towards wide-eyed panic, the kind of mugging you’ve seen from him before, and Edgar Ortega at Loud and Clear Reviews argued the film is “undermined by the shadow of its lead”. I think that’s half right. The baggage is real, but the performance itself isn’t the problem. One early critic put him up with George C. Scott among the best modern Scrooges. That’s a stretch, though not a silly one.

Johnny Depp as a scowling Ebenezer Scrooge in a top hat and red scarf on a busy Victorian shopping street in Ebenezer (2026)
Depp’s Scrooge at his flintiest. Image © Paramount Pictures, via the official featurette.

2. The Story and Setup (Ebenezer, 2026, Paramount)

What makes it stand out: For all the “story you don’t know” marketing, this is a largely faithful A Christmas Carol with a darker coat of paint.

Key data: Nathaniel Halpern’s screenplay keeps Dickens’ Victorian London, Christmas Eve setting, Marley’s warning and the three spirits, and runs 116 minutes.

Why it matters: The film sold itself on surprise, and it mostly delivers the version you already know.

The tagline is “The name you know, the story you don’t.” That’s the film’s biggest problem in a sentence, because you do know this story, and Ebenezer doesn’t change much of it. Seven years after Jacob Marley’s death, Scrooge is still counting coins and turning away anyone who asks for help. On Christmas Eve, Marley’s ghost arrives in chains and promises three visitors. You know the rest.

There are additions. The film spends longer on Scrooge’s family and his failed romance than most versions do, Attractions Magazine’s Dani Meyering noted it adds ghosts beyond the traditional three, and Ian McKellen’s Marley gets an extended stretch while he’s still alive. Those are good ideas. They just don’t reshape the story so much as decorate it.

Halpern has a background in strange, cerebral television, and I kept waiting for a bigger swing. It never really comes. That’s the core of the Rotten Tomatoes consensus, which says the film “plays things too safe to stand out amongst its long line of remakes”, and on this point the consensus is right. If you’ve seen two or three Carols already, you’ll be ahead of the film most of the time.

3. Ian McKellen’s Marley and the Opening (Ebenezer, 2026, Paramount)

What makes it stand out: Ebenezer gives Jacob Marley a life before his death, and Ian McKellen makes the most of it.

Key data: Den of Geek reports Marley appears alive in an extended opening sequence before returning as a chained ghost.

Why it matters: It’s the one structural change that genuinely deepens the story, because Scrooge’s warning comes from someone we’ve actually met.

Most adaptations treat Marley as a plot device: a face in a door knocker, then a speech. Here he’s a person first, Scrooge’s partner in a business that made them both rich and lonely. When McKellen returns in chains, begging his old partner to change, it lands harder because we’ve already met the man.

McKellen is 87 and still knows exactly how to hold a scene. His ghost warns and pleads rather than simply moaning, and that’s a smarter reading than the rattling phantom of so many versions.

The door knocker scene is also one of the film’s cleverest moments. Without spoiling it, West knows you’re expecting the face to appear, and he plays with that expectation. It’s a reminder of what the director does best: timing a scare so it lands a beat away from where you’ve braced for it.

Johnny Depp's Scrooge in a nightcap holding a candle in the dark, from the second official trailer for Ti West's Ebenezer
Christmas Eve at Scrooge’s house is where West’s horror instincts show. Image © Paramount Pictures, via official trailer 2.

4. The Three Spirits: Riseborough and Tillman (Ebenezer, 2026, Paramount)

What makes it stand out: Andrea Riseborough’s Ghost of Christmas Past is the most memorable thing in the film after Depp, and Tramell Tillman’s Present is a sharp, funny surprise.

Key data: Riseborough plays the Ghost of Christmas Past with solid white eyes; Tillman, best known for Severance, plays a surly, constantly eating Ghost of Christmas Present.

Why it matters: The spirits are where West’s horror background is supposed to pay off, and in two of the three cases it does.

Riseborough is extraordinary here. Her spirit is curious and almost childlike, with those blank white eyes, and the film gives her a twist on Dickens: she’s doing penance for wasting her own days. It’s a small invention that adds real weight, and Riseborough plays it with a stillness that’s quietly upsetting. The schoolhouse sequence, which opens with a jump scare that catches you completely off guard, is the highlight of the film.

Tillman’s Present is a different beast. Instead of the jolly giant in a green robe, he’s curt, impatient and always chewing. He starts out as comic relief and gets considerably colder as his visit goes on. Tillman has a gift for menace hidden under politeness, which anyone who’s watched Severance will recognise, and it suits a spirit who isn’t interested in whether Scrooge feels good.

The third spirit I’ll leave for you to see. It’s where the film’s bleakest imagery lives, and it’s closer to the gothic horror the trailers promised.

5. The Supporting Cast: Grint, Claflin and Ridley (Ebenezer, 2026, Paramount)

What makes it stand out: A very good supporting cast is mostly given very little to do.

Key data: Rupert Grint plays Bob Cratchit and Sam Claflin plays Scrooge’s nephew Fred, with Daisy Ridley, Ellie Bamber, Arthur Conti (as the young Ebenezer), Henry Lloyd-Hughes and Charlie Murphy in support.

Why it matters: A Christmas Carol only works if the people Scrooge wrongs feel real, and here they mostly feel like furniture.

This is where the film loses a star. Rupert Grint is fine as Bob Cratchit, warm and harried, but he’s barely written. Mike BC called him “underwhelming” while admitting he’s “not bad”, and that’s about right. It isn’t Grint’s fault. The script is so focused on Scrooge and his ghosts that the Cratchit household becomes a quick stop rather than the emotional centre it should be.

Claflin’s Fred has the same issue. The nephew is supposed to be the story’s stubborn optimist, the man who keeps inviting Scrooge to dinner every year regardless. Claflin has the charm for it, but he’s in and out too quickly. Daisy Ridley, who gets one of the trailer’s most striking shots, is similarly underused.

The one real bright spot is the boy playing Tiny Tim. Freddie Lee-Grey has the unenviable job of making a character who’s been parodied for 180 years feel sincere, and he manages it. When the film does reach for tears, it’s mostly through him and Depp.

Daisy Ridley in a Victorian gown and pearl necklace in a candlelit red parlour in Ebenezer (2026)
Daisy Ridley is one of several strong names left with too little to do. Image © Paramount Pictures, via trailer footage.

6. Ti West’s Direction and the Hammer Influence (Ebenezer, 2026, Paramount)

What makes it stand out: West models the film on Hammer’s Victorian horror, but keeps his own edges sanded down for a studio Christmas release.

Key data: It’s West’s first film for a major studio, on a reported $38 million budget, after his X, Pearl and MaXXXine trilogy for A24; MaXXXine made about $22 million worldwide in total.

Why it matters: Hiring the director of X to make A Christmas Carol was the most interesting decision behind this film, and the result shows both why it worked and where it held back.

West has said plainly that Hammer Studios was his model. “Hammer has just such a pleasing aesthetic to me,” he told Den of Geek, and you can see it everywhere: the saturated candle colours, the old-fashioned opening credits, the sense of a stagey, lovingly built London. It’s the most coherent visual idea any Christmas Carol has had in years.

What’s missing is West’s mischief. Pearl and X were nasty, funny and properly strange. Here he’s clearly working within a brief. There’s a nod to A Nightmare on Elm Street, with Scrooge swallowed by his own bed, which West says was in the script before Depp was cast (Depp told him to keep it). It’s a fun moment. But it’s also about as far as the film goes in playing with its star or its genre.

The pacing is steady rather than gripping. At 116 minutes, Ebenezer is long for a story this familiar, and you feel it whenever the film is retracing beats you already know. West’s control is still obvious in individual scenes, especially the jump scares, but the whole thing feels more careful than his best work.

7. The Look, Sound and Tyler Bates’ Score (Ebenezer, 2026, Paramount)

What makes it stand out: On craft alone, Ebenezer is one of the best-looking Christmas films in years.

Key data: Tyler Bates, who scored X, Pearl and MaXXXine for West, composed the music, and the opening credits use John Williams’ Carol of the Bells arrangement from Home Alone (1990); the film was reportedly shot in Dublin and London.

Why it matters: Even critics who disliked the film agree it looks and sounds terrific, which is a big part of why it’s still worth seeing on a big screen.

Richard Roeper called it “a great-looking film with terrific production design, sound and cinematography”, and on this he’s spot on. London here is all snow, gaslight and dark corridors, with deep reds and greens that look like a Hammer poster come to life. The interiors are better still: Scrooge’s house is cavernous and cold, a place where every candle seems to be losing a fight with the dark.

Tyler Bates’ score is the unsung hero. It swells for the big ghost moments, then drops to near-silence just before the scares, which is exactly the trick that makes them work. Using the Home Alone version of Carol of the Bells over the opening credits is a cheeky move that tells you early on this is a film made by someone who loves Christmas movies as much as horror.

Christmas carols turn up across different time periods in the story too, and they’re well chosen. If nothing else, it’s a film that sounds like Christmas, and you’d be surprised how many festive releases don’t.

Johnny Depp's Scrooge tipping his top hat with a fingerless glove against a misty blue background in Ti West's Ebenezer
Ti West borrows Hammer’s gothic palette for Scrooge’s London. Image © Paramount Pictures, via the official featurette.

8. How Scary Is Ebenezer? (Ebenezer, 2026, Paramount)

What makes it stand out: It’s spookier than most Christmas Carols, but nowhere near the horror film some of the marketing implied.

Key data: Rated PG-13 in the US for frightening material, with no BBFC rating confirmed for the UK yet; West describes the tone as “hard-PG”.

Why it matters: Families need to know whether to bring the kids, and horror fans need to know whether to bother.

Think of it as a ghost story rather than a horror film. There are several very effective jump scares, a couple of properly eerie sequences, and some bleak imagery once the third spirit arrives. Nothing is gruesome. Attractions Magazine found nothing “particularly gruesome” either, while warning against taking young or easily frightened children, and I’d say the same.

In practice, it’s about right for most children of 11 or 12 and up, which is the age Dickens’ original was written to frighten anyway. Under that, think carefully. The Ghost of Christmas Past’s white eyes alone will stay with a seven-year-old for weeks.

For grown-up horror fans, the honest answer is that this is West in a lower gear. If you loved the cruelty of X or the unhinged energy of Pearl, temper your expectations. This is a film made to be shown to families at Christmas, and it never forgets that.

9. The ‘Gray Area’ Scrooge: What Ebenezer Changes From Dickens (Ebenezer, 2026, Paramount)

What makes it stand out: West and Halpern try to make Scrooge’s meanness understandable, not just villainous.

Key data: The film adds street scammers pretending to be disabled and charity workers who spend donations on themselves, and West told Den of Geek he wanted to “put some gray area into it”.

Why it matters: It’s the film’s most original idea, and the one that comes closest to justifying a new version.

This is the bit I wish the film had leaned into harder. West’s idea is that Scrooge’s distrust of charity isn’t pure villainy. The London around him is full of people working an angle, and when he refuses to give, he’s wrong, but “I know where he’s coming from,” as West put it. It’s an interesting tweak for a story that usually draws its moral lines very neatly.

The trouble is that the idea doesn’t reshape the story. Once the spirits arrive, Ebenezer goes back to the standard Dickens path: Scrooge is shown the cost of his coldness, and he learns. The scammers and the greedy charity collectors make Scrooge easier to understand, but they never become an argument the film really has with itself.

Compared with Dickens, the bigger change is tone. In the novella, the spirits nudge Scrooge, sometimes sternly, towards joy. Here they’re harder and less patient. That bleaker mood is the real difference from the book, and it works well when the film commits to it.

Close-up of Johnny Depp's Scrooge grinning in a black bowler hat and knitted scarf on a sunlit street in Ebenezer (2026)
Depp plays Scrooge’s change slowly rather than as a last-minute flip. Image © Paramount Pictures, via trailer footage.

10. How It Compares to Other Christmas Carols (Ebenezer, 2026, Paramount)

What makes it stand out: It’s a solid mid-table Carol: better than Robert Zemeckis’s 2009 motion-capture version, well short of the classics.

Key data: The best-loved screen versions include Alastair Sim’s Scrooge (1951), George C. Scott’s TV film (1984), The Muppet Christmas Carol with Michael Caine (1992) and Patrick Stewart’s TV version (1999); Disney’s Jim Carrey film opened to about $30.1 million in 2009.

Why it matters: With dozens of adaptations a click away, the question isn’t whether Ebenezer is good, it’s whether it’s good enough to pick over the ones you already love.

Alastair Sim’s Scrooge is still the benchmark for a reason, and The Muppet Christmas Carol remains the warmest, funniest and, oddly, most faithful version of Dickens’ prose. Ebenezer doesn’t touch either. It lacks Sim’s moral weight and the Muppets’ joy.

The closest comparison is Zemeckis’s A Christmas Carol, another attempt to make the story darker and more frightening. Ebenezer is better. Its scares are built with practical sets, real actors and proper timing rather than weightless motion capture, and Depp’s Scrooge is a more interesting creature than Carrey’s.

Against George C. Scott and Patrick Stewart, it’s a closer call. Both of those gave you a Scrooge of real gravity in a more modest production. Depp’s is funnier, West’s world is far more beautiful, but the earlier versions understood that the Cratchits matter. If you’ve got the 1984 film on a shelf, you don’t need this one. If you want something new for the cinema this December, it’s a decent option.

11. What Other Critics Got Right and Wrong (Ebenezer, 2026, Paramount)

What makes it stand out: Critics are split almost exactly down the middle, while audiences are far kinder.

Key data: Ebenezer holds 54% on Rotten Tomatoes from 126 reviews, against a 90% Popcornmeter from more than 500 verified audience ratings; it opened at No. 1 in North America with an estimated $19 million.

Why it matters: The gap between critics and audiences tells you a lot about who’ll enjoy this.

The harshest notices go too far. Kyle Smith in the Wall Street Journal said the film “sets itself up for a charge of being superfluous that it can’t answer”, and MaryAnn Johanson called it “utterly superfluous”. I understand the frustration, but superfluous isn’t the same as bad. There’s plenty of craft and one fine lead performance here.

At the other end, Mike BC’s 9/10 at But Why Tho?, calling it “quite possibly the greatest adaptation of A Christmas Carol ever filmed”, is far too generous. It’s not even the greatest Christmas Carol with a Michael in it.

The critics I’m closest to are the ones in the middle. Allen Almachar at The MacGuffin called it “completely and utterly fine” and said it “looks great, has terrific production values, features a strong cast”. Adam Graham at the Detroit News gave it a B-minus and said it “doesn’t break any new ground, nor does it try to”. That’s the film exactly.

The 90% audience score and the No. 1 opening, from our Ebenezer box office takeaways, suggest that people who buy a ticket expecting a handsome Christmas ghost story with Depp in it come out happy. Critics wanted a Ti West film. Audiences wanted A Christmas Carol. Audiences got what they came for.

12. Who Should Watch Ebenezer, and Who Should Skip It (Ebenezer, 2026, Paramount)

What makes it stand out: It’s an easy recommendation for one audience and an easy skip for another.

Key data: In UK cinemas from 13 November 2026, running 116 minutes, with a US PG-13 rating and no UK streaming date announced.

Why it matters: At cinema prices in December, knowing which side of the line you’re on saves you a tenner.

Watch it if: you want a festive night out that’s a bit darker than the usual Christmas fare, you’re curious to see Depp back in a studio film, you love gothic period design, or you’ve got teenagers who’ve outgrown the Muppets but aren’t ready for full horror. It’s a genuinely good-looking big-screen experience, and the score alone makes the cinema worth it over waiting for streaming.

Skip it if: you came for Ti West at full strength, you’ve seen A Christmas Carol more times than you can count and want a real reinvention, or you can’t separate Depp from his off-screen history. Also skip it with very young children; those ghosts are not for under-tens.

If you’re torn, here’s the simplest test. Did you enjoy Guillermo del Toro’s Crimson Peak more for its look than its story? Then Ebenezer will work for you. If you need a story to surprise you, it won’t.

Filmoria’s Final Verdict on Ebenezer

Ebenezer is a beautifully made, well-acted and mostly faithful A Christmas Carol that promised to be something stranger. Johnny Depp is good, sometimes very good, as a dry, slow-thawing Scrooge, Andrea Riseborough is haunting as the Ghost of Christmas Past, and Ti West’s Hammer-inspired London is a joy to look at. But a cautious script, an underused supporting cast and a smart “gray area” idea that never fully pays off keep it from earning its place among the great versions. It’s a solid three-star Christmas outing, more than the “superfluous” verdict suggests and nowhere near a new classic. Filmoria rating: 3/5.

Sources: Rotten Tomatoes (Ebenezer critic and audience scores), Den of Geek (Ti West interview), But Why Tho? review, Attractions Magazine review, Variety (trailer 2 and cast), Paramount Pictures (official trailer).

Frequently Asked Questions

When did Ebenezer come out in UK cinemas?

Ebenezer was released in UK and Irish cinemas on Friday 13 November 2026 by Paramount Pictures International, the same day as its US release.

Is Ebenezer worth watching?

Yes, if you want a good-looking, slightly spooky Christmas Carol with a strong Johnny Depp performance; Filmoria gives it 3 out of 5 because the story plays it safe.

Is Ebenezer a horror film?

No, Ebenezer is a gothic ghost story rather than a full horror film; it has jump scares and eerie scenes but nothing gruesome, and Ti West calls it hard-PG.

What age is Ebenezer suitable for?

Ebenezer is rated PG-13 in the US for frightening material, so it suits most children of about 11 or 12 and up; no UK BBFC rating has been confirmed in the sources we checked.

Who plays the ghosts in Ebenezer?

Ian McKellen plays Jacob Marley, Andrea Riseborough plays the Ghost of Christmas Past and Tramell Tillman plays the Ghost of Christmas Present.

Who plays Bob Cratchit in Ebenezer?

Rupert Grint plays Bob Cratchit in Ebenezer, with Sam Claflin as Scrooge’s nephew Fred.

What is the Rotten Tomatoes score for Ebenezer?

Ebenezer has a 54% critics score on Rotten Tomatoes from 126 reviews and a 90% Popcornmeter audience score.

How much did Ebenezer cost to make?

Ebenezer has a reported net production budget of $38 million, and it opened at No. 1 in North America with an estimated $19 million.

Is Ebenezer on Netflix or Paramount Plus?

No, Ebenezer is only in cinemas for now; a streaming date has not yet been confirmed for the UK.

Does Ebenezer have a post-credits scene?

No, Ebenezer has no mid-credits or post-credits scene, though the end credits include some visual touches and a short closing message.

📸 Follow us on Instagram for daily film, TV & gaming news: @filmoriauk

Kevin Bennett, Filmoria

Kevin Bennett

Covers genre cinema for Filmoria: horror, thrillers and the sort of low-budget film that finds its audience years after release. Also writes on physical media and restorations.